Andrew Wells vs. The First — 7x16 “The Storyteller” & 7x14 “The First Date”
Additionally, his scene with Anya in End of Days 7.21 regarding the ointment can be considered part of this dialogue.
BtVS Rewatch 2012-2013; One Gifset Per Episode
➞ 7x14 - First Date
Xander: I’m going gay. I’ve decided I’m turning gay. WIllow, gay me up. Come on, let’s gay.
Xander: You heard me. Just tell me what to do. I’m mentally undressing Scott Bakula right now. That’s a start, isn’t it?
Andrew: Captain Archer…
Xander: Come on, lets get this gay show on the gay road. Help me out here.
Buffy: What if you start attracting male demons?
Dawn: Clem always liked you.